"The band is wise beyond its members' years, with lush instrumentation and dynamic arrangements. Sweater Weather is Chapel Hill indie rock that needs to be seen - and viewers need not be constrained to the Triangle."
- Morgan Ellis, The Daily Tar Heel

"It's a small miracle that a project so ambitious from such young musicians is a success. It's easy to imagine all the disparate elements of the group churning out cacophonous mush. Instead, the ensemble is remarkably in sync, a unified front of argyle and pumas. It's tough to pin down Sweater Weather: their songs are at times slow and meandering, at other times thrashing and forceful. Lindsay Ellerbe's cello adds soothing accents to the slower moments, Tim Phillips' trumpet lends a rollicking, marching-band feel, and Bobby Sweatt's percussion is a force to be reckoned with."
- Abby Lavin, The DCist

"At its best, Sweater Weather's eight members and several dozen instruments are joists and studs, building up and out instead of in or around."
- Grayson Currin, The Independent Weekly

"It's pastoral and gentle, but moves beyond being merely pleasant through expansive arrangments and song forms."
- The Oak Room